Crone with a Machete

The Shrew Was Never Meant to Be Tamed

✦ ✦ ✦

Maybe the shrew was never meant to be tamed. Maybe she was meant to be on her own.

We have been handed this story for over four hundred years as a comedy. A sharp-tongued woman, a swaggering man, a little starvation, a little sleep deprivation, and by the final act she is kneeling, offering to put her hand beneath her husband's foot. Curtain. Applause. Everyone goes home laughing.

But look at who Kate actually is. She isn't a shrew. She's a force of nature. She sees every dynamic in her father's house, every bargain, every pretense, every quiet favoritism, and she names it out loud. A force of nature doesn't fit inside a household. It moves through it, and everything around it arranges itself in its pull. That's what Padua could never forgive her for.

I have sat with women for over thirty years. In the salon chair, on the bodywork table, in the quiet of a session. I have heard this story told a thousand ways, and none of them were funny. So let's take it apart. Not to cancel Shakespeare. To read what he actually wrote, and what the world decided to see instead.

I Was Cast as Kate

I know this woman from the inside. In acting school we workshopped this play, and I was cast as Kate. Everyone said I was perfect for the role. Nobody meant it as an insult, and back then I didn't hear it as one.

The scene was electric. My Petruchio was a natural, and clever enough to pull tricks in the middle of it that I never saw coming, so every time we played it, it was alive. I'll be honest: it was a delight. That's the seduction of this play. Played well, the fight feels like a dance between equals.

But a dance is something two people choose. The play never lets Kate choose. It only lets her lose beautifully.

Not the Marrying Type

A few years later I was twenty-one, working in a salon. There was a redhead there, Rebecca, and I adored her. Soft, demure, beautiful in a way she couldn't see, like she'd wandered in from some gentler world. Everyone was always trying to set her up, find her a man.

So one day I said, well, why don't you set me up with him? The room went quiet. And then somebody finally said it: you're not the marrying type.

I was twenty-one, and I could not wrap my brain around it. I'm sixty-four, and I still can't. What exactly is the type of woman not worth marrying? The one who talks back? The one who knows what she wants? The one who doesn't need rescuing?

There is no such type. There's only a culture that sorts women into keepers and leftovers, then acts like the sorting is nature. It's not okay. It wasn't okay in Padua, and it wasn't okay in that salon.

The Bargain Nobody Asked Her to Sign

Look at how the play is built. Bianca, the sweet younger sister, has suitors lined up around the block. But their father, Baptista, makes a rule: no one marries Bianca until somebody takes Katherine off his hands.

Sit with that. Kate's existence is the obstacle. Her unmarried, unbroken self is the thing standing between her sister and happiness, between the suitors and their prize, between her father and a tidy household. The men don't court Kate. They hire a man to get rid of her so they can get to the girl they actually want.

And Kate knows it. She says it out loud to her father: Bianca is his treasure, she must have a husband, and Kate will dance barefoot at her sister's wedding and "lead apes in hell," the old fate of the unmarried woman. That is not a shrew talking. That is a woman who has read the room her whole life and knows exactly where she stands in it. Second. Difficult. In the way.

Think of Dorothy and her ruby slippers. Kate had them on the whole time. A whole town hung its future on whether one woman would bend: her father's peace, her sister's wedding, the suitors' plans, a stranger's fortune. Nothing in Padua could move until Kate said yes. That is power. That is more power than anyone else in the play holds.

She just didn't know it. Kate saw the whole game clearly, and still she stayed. That's the trap. She thought her power was her tongue, so she fought. She sparred, she snapped, she broke a lute over a man's head. But fighting kept her in the room, playing their game on their board, feeding them the very energy they needed. Her real power was her no. Her absence.

When a force of nature pulls its energy out of a situation, it leaves a hole, and everything left behind collapses into it. If Kate had walked, there would be no one left to blame. Baptista would have to face his favoritism. Bianca would have to drop the act. The suitors would turn their knives on each other. Padua would implode.

And here's the sick and twisted part. Everyone around her knew her power better than she did. That's why they worked so hard to break it. You don't spend that much effort taming a woman who doesn't matter. They needed her yes, so they starved her until she gave it. Nobody ever tells the woman she's wearing the slippers. Not her father, not her sister, not the man who marries her. They need her to keep believing she's the problem, so she never finds out she's the key.

Why the World Needs Her Broken

A woman who will not perform is a mirror. Stand next to her and you see your own performance.

That is Kate's real crime. Not her tongue. Her refusal. Every man in Padua who meets her feels the ground shift, because she does not smile on cue or soften her truth to protect his comfort. So they name her. Shrew. Devil. Wildcat. Once you've named a woman, you no longer have to hear her. You only have to fix her.

And Bianca? Bianca is the good one. Quiet, pleasing, admired. But a pleasing woman standing next to a free one feels the cost of every bow she has made. The free sister becomes a question the good sister can't afford to answer: what if I didn't have to? So the family does what families do. They make the wild one the problem, so the tame one never has to feel what she gave up.

I've watched this in real families for decades. One daughter carries the fire, one carries the approval, and the whole system is organized around putting the fire out. Not because she's wrong. Because her rightness is unbearable.

The Taming Is a Method, Not a Romance

Petruchio tells us exactly what he's doing. He compares Kate to a falcon he is training: keep her sharp and empty, don't let her sleep, don't let her eat, until she comes to the hand. That is not love talk. That is the language of breaking an animal, and he says it to the audience with a wink.

So he starves her. He keeps her awake. He throws out the food and the gown and the cap, always "for her own good." And then comes the scene everyone calls charming: on the road home he calls the sun the moon, and she has to agree or they turn back. She finally says it. Call it the sun, call it the moon, call it whatever you like, and that is what it will be for Kate.

That is the moment she breaks. Not when she loves him. When she stops trusting her own eyes. Every woman who has ever been told she's too sensitive, too much, remembering it wrong, knows that scene from the inside. You don't tame a woman by beating her. You tame her by making her doubt the sky.

The Nice Girl Was the Performance

Here's the twist hiding in plain sight. Read it again and watch Bianca.

She's the sweet one, the virtuous one, the one worth waiting for. Meanwhile she flirts with her disguised tutors and slips off to marry one in secret, behind her father's back. The moment the ring is on, the sweetness is gone. When her husband calls, she won't come. When he complains he lost money betting on her, she tells him that's his own foolishness.

And Kate? Yes, she's rough early on. She ties up her sister's hands. She smashes a lute over a tutor's head. That's what a cornered creature does when the whole house is built around her being the problem. But she never pretended to be anything other than what she was.

So who's the shrew? Bianca played virtue to win a husband. Kate was honest from her first line. The play calls the honest woman the bitch and the strategist the angel. We've been reading the labels, not the women.

Then She Turns and Breaks Her Sister

Here is the part that should keep us up at night. The final scene is a bet. The husbands wager on whose wife will come when called. Bianca, the prize, refuses, of course. The "good" sister was never tame. She was only performing until the ring was on.

Kate comes. And then Petruchio hands her the stage and tells her to instruct these headstrong women in their duty. So Kate, the one who was starved into agreement, turns to her own sister and lectures her. Your husband is your lord, your life, your keeper. Put your hand beneath his foot.

This is how it works. This is how it has always worked. The world breaks the wild woman, and then it hands her the hammer. She becomes the enforcer, the aunt who says don't be so dramatic, the mother who says that's just how men are, the friend who says keep the peace. She breaks herself so no man feels threatened, and then she breaks the next woman so she doesn't have to feel alone in her cage.

The original wound was the sisters set against each other. The final wound is the sisters made to finish each other off. And the men laugh, collect their winnings, and go to bed.

What She Was Meant For

Picture a different ending. No suitor gets hired. No one makes a bet. Kate simply walks out of Padua.

She pulls her energy out, and the house caves in on itself. Baptista turns on Bianca. Bianca turns on her suitors. The suitors turn on each other. Without the force of nature to blame, they finally have to look at one another, and none of them likes what they see.

She was never a shrew. She was a woman built for a life of her own: her own land, her own work, her own tongue, answering to the sun as the sun. The old world had names for women like her. Wise woman. Herb woman. The one at the edge of the village everybody whispered about and everybody visited in the night when the baby was sick.

And not much has changed. Four hundred years later, we still don't know how to bring this woman into the community. We still see her as a threat. We fear her, because she sees right through us and no one can run game on her. So we keep her at the edge, the way Padua did.

Underneath the fear is something quieter: who we decide deserves respect. A married woman is granted a standing the unmarried woman never is, as if the ring were a door she walked through and came out the other side worthy. Mrs. carries weight. Miss stays a girl's word, no matter how silver her hair grows. She can build a life with her own two hands, nurse a village through its fevers, bury her parents, outlive half the men who dismissed her, and still be treated as though her life hasn't quite begun. As though no man has vouched for her yet.

Yet she is the one who will always be there. Come to her with humility and honesty and her door is open. We just never learned how to approach her. We keep coming with flattery, or control, or a hammer, and then call her difficult when none of it works. A woman on her own isn't a failure of the story. She is a whole other story, one the culture still doesn't have the stomach to tell.

And Bianca? Freed from the comparison, she might have finally found out who she was underneath the pleasing. That's the thing nobody says. Breaking Kate didn't save Bianca. It just made sure neither of them got to be whole.

Everything Became a Question

Long before it was fashionable, I started questioning everything. I didn't go to college. I took the classes that called to me and followed my own interests, not anyone's idea of who I should be. My mother wanted me in banking.

So I became a manicurist. In 1982 it paid twenty-five dollars an hour, it gave me freedom over my days, and it put me in a room full of creatives. However dysfunctional that salon was, every single person in it was living in their uniqueness. I didn't know it then, but that room was my first teacher.

Then, in my thirties, the kundalini woke me up, and the questions went all the way down. I examined everything, including the things we're told are sacred: marriage, family, children. I sat with them honestly, for years.

Here's where I landed. Every woman has to choose what is right for her. That's the whole answer, and somehow it's the one nobody can hold.

Marriage has become a political football, kicked from both sides of the field. I'm on both sides. If a woman wants to stay single, for whatever her reasons, let her. If a woman aches to have babies, I understand that too. Some women are born to be mothers, and we need mothers.

And we need wild women. Medicine women. Herb women. When your work is tending the whole village, who tends your family? Some of us were never meant to keep one hearth. We were meant to keep the fire for everyone.

That's what nobody in Padua could see. Kate had a different purpose. But she was her father's property and her sister's obstacle, so she was tortured into submission. For some women, that is still what marriage feels like. Not all women. But every woman deserves to sit with herself, honestly, and ask which path she is actually here to walk.

That's the conversation we never finish. We keep arguing about which path is right, when the harmony is so simple: each woman has her own.

Why I Wrote Aaurelia

This is why I wrote Aaurelia Gold Heart. I didn't write a woman so wounded she runs away. I wrote an awakened woman who keeps choosing. Not because someone hurt her, not because something didn't work out. She takes the left turn, then the right, again and again, because it's her path and she knows it.

She is the Kate who walked out of Padua. She is the wise woman at the edge of the village, and she isn't apologizing for it.

And she is for the women who stayed. The ones who did as they were told, kept the peace, agreed the sun was the moon because it was easier than the fight.

Padua never really closed. It just learned to whisper. Nobody needs a father's rule or a husband's wager anymore. A glance does the job. The friend who stops calling once she's married. The question at the dinner party, "And is there a Mr.?" The way a room warms to a ring, and cools just slightly when there isn't one. We tell ourselves all that is behind us. It isn't. It only got quieter.

Aaurelia is for both sisters, the one who walked and the one who stayed. The door out of Padua is the same door for each of us.

To the Kates Still Standing

If you have been called difficult your whole life, listen to an old woman. You were not too much. You were the one who wouldn't lie about the sky.

You don't have to be tamed to be loved. You don't have to kneel to belong. And when the world hands you the hammer and asks you to break the next girl, the bold one, the loud one, the one who reminds you of who you used to be, put it down.

Because here is what Padua never wanted us to learn. It doesn't matter which direction the voice comes from. Marry by thirty. Have the babies. Be the girl boss. Hustle harder. Be sexier, be more of a slut, and call it freedom. Put the career first. Put the kids first. Every voice that tells a woman how to live her life, and then shames her when she doesn't, has a name. It's the patriarchy, even when it wears a pantsuit, even when it speaks in a woman's voice. And it doesn't fall to a fight. It falls, quietly, every time a woman chooses her own path and keeps walking it.

Tell her the sun is the sun.

Then walk out of Padua together.

✦

If you've been reading me a while, you know I keep coming back to this. Yes, I'm still waving this flag, and I'll keep waving it until I see women walking their own paths without asking anyone's permission. Every new script gets sold as freedom from the last one. The only question that cuts through all of them is the one nobody else can answer for you: what is your true divine nature?

Narayan